Why People Keep Fainting at the Mansfield Reformatory

Part ghost story, part medical mystery — all classic Ohio weirdness.

In partnership with

👮‍♂️ The creepiest haunted tours in Ohio
🏢 The weird history of one of NEO’s most incredible buildings
🥧 The dreamiest local, all-natural, made-by-hand pie 🤤

Does your car insurance cover what really matters?

Not all car insurance is created equal. Minimum liability coverage may keep you legal on the road, but it often won’t be enough to cover the full cost of an accident. Without proper limits, you could be left paying thousands out of pocket. The right policy ensures you and your finances are protected. Check out Money’s car insurance tool to get the coverage you actually need.

COMPARE COVERAGE

👆 Psst…every click adds up!👆
🥰 Thank you for helping Clevelandish thrive. 🥰

There’s something about October in Ohio - the air goes crisp and apple-sharp, the trees look like they’re on fire, and even the sun feels a little haunted.

It’s the perfect season for ghost stories, and the Mansfield Reformatory might just be the crown jewel of them all. (This blog post has some cool historic photos of the construction & more.)

Picture this: a hulking gray fortress rising out of the cornfields, its towers cutting into the fog like a Gothic cathedral that lost its faith. The doors groan as you enter. It smells faintly of dust, cold metal, and old secrets.

A guide’s flashlight beam skims across peeling paint, iron bars, and a thousand tiny echoes of footsteps that stopped decades ago.

And somewhere between the east cell block and the chapel, you feel it - that prickle on the back of your neck. The air shifts. It’s heavier here, charged, like walking through someone’s unfinished sentence.

Your chest tightens a little.

You swallow.

That’s when it happens.

Someone gasps. Then someone drops.

And that is the one sound you absolutely don’t want to hear on a haunted tour - a body hitting the floor. 😅 Every flashlight jerks up, the guide stops mid-sentence, and suddenly everyone’s holding their breath like, I hope that was just low blood sugar. Can you imagine? I’d need a change of pants and a therapist. 😂

👉 See the Reformatory’s haunted lineup →

A Prison Built Like a Gothic Cathedral (because why not?)

Construction started in 1886, when the architects apparently couldn’t decide whether to build a church or a nightmare.

It’s all turrets, arches, and shadows - beautiful in daylight, absolutely chilling at dusk. Thousands of inmates passed through over the years. Between the sorrow, the isolation cells known as “the Hole,” and decades of restless energy, it’s no wonder people swear the building hums.

It later became famous for The Shawshank Redemption, but locals know the real stories aren’t Hollywood. After dark, people hear voices, see flashes of light, feel their clothes tugged. Even the staff will tell you they don’t like being alone in the east cell block.

(Read about OSR’s haunted tours)

👉 See the Reformatory’s real ghost stories & dark past here.

There’s more to learn at hauntedus.com

The Chapel, the “Hole,” and the Drop Heard ’Round the Tour

The fainting doesn’t happen just anywhere. It’s the chapel, where sunlight filters through grimy glass in pale ribbons, and solitary confinement, where the air goes still.

That’s where people go glassy-eyed, grab a wall, and slide gracefully toward the floor.

Guides say it’s the energy - too much emotion, too many echoes - pressing down on the sensitive ones. Doctors say it’s probably vasovagal syncope, which is science-speak for “your body got overwhelmed and hit the off switch.”

The truth? Maybe a little of both.

You spend an hour in a place built to break people’s spirits, surrounded by stories of men who never left, and suddenly your knees decide to stage a protest. Makes sense to me.

(Cleveland Clinic explains the real fainting thing here)

Haunted or Human — Either Way, It’s Ohio Weirdness at Its Finest

Whether you’re a skeptic or a believer, something about Mansfield’s Reformatory gets under your skin. Maybe it’s leftover energy. Maybe it’s your body’s way of saying, “Nope, I’ve heard enough about ghost prisoners for one night.”

But as the tour moves on, the lights flicker, someone laughs nervously, and everyone steps just a little closer together - because who wants to be alone in a hallway where the living and the dead both have stories to tell?

So if you go this weekend, bring water, courage, and maybe someone to catch you — just in case the ghosts get playful. And if you do hit the floor? Don’t worry. At Mansfield, even the spirits appreciate a little dramatic flair. 👻

🔗 plan your visit 🔗

For the curious (and the brave):

  • HauntedUS – Visitor stories and creepy highlights from inside the prison.
  • Cleveland Clinic – The (very human) reason some visitors faint mid-ghost story.

Want to see what all the drama’s about? 👀 Step inside Mansfield’s jaw-dropping Reformatory →

P.S. After all that ghost talk, I think we’ve earned something sweet — like this decadent Sweet Potato Pie with Chocolate Ganache and Pecans from Gray House Pies. It might actually change your life. Their pies are hand-made from all-natural, high-quality ingredients, and they’ve been in Westlake since 2004. #local 🥧

Interested in reaching our Cleveland audience? We have tons of opportunities to get eyeballs on your biz. Click here to learn more | Click here to book a call with us

The Newsletter That Shows You The Real Cleveland

Most local media covers crime, politics, or only focuses on downtown Cleveland. We shine a light on the entire region — from the suburbs to the lake, from historic landmarks to small family-owned businesses.

Our lens is positive, practical, and rooted in real local life.

Proudly Cleveland-based

Thousands of local subscribers and growing every week

Curated by locals who live here, raise families here, and know the area inside and out

Sign up and join the 30,000+ subscribers who already receive our newsletter
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
“This is the first newsletter I actually look forward to opening. I’ve discovered new restaurants and parks I never knew existed — all in my own backyard.”
Sarah M., Mentor